Friday, October 31, 2008
Constitutional Law Professors’ Statement About Proposition 8
***
Proposition 8, on the ballot this November, proposes a constitutional amendment that would
eliminate the right to marry that same-sex couples in California currently possess. We recognize
that people of integrity can differ in their views of the meaning of marriage. But people who want to take the right to marry away from same-sex couples should not rely on misleading claims about the current state of the law or about what Proposition 8 will do. As professors who teach and write about constitutional law, family law, and related subjects, we emphasize the following basic points.
First, Proposition 8 would change existing California law and would require the state to
discriminate against gay men and lesbians. Proposition 8 would forbid government officials from
according gay men and lesbians a fundamental right they now enjoy and that all other adults in
California will continue to enjoy: the right to marry a person of their choice. Just as California’s
long ago-repudiated ban on interracial marriage constituted racial discrimination, so too, a ban on same-sex marriage would constitute discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation. The ability of same-sex couples to enter into registered domestic partnerships does not eliminate that discrimination. Thus, the claim made by some of Proposition 8’s supporters that the amendment does not discriminate against gay men and lesbians is simply false.
Second, the claim that Proposition 8 is necessary to protect the tax exemptions of churches
that refuse to solemnize or recognize marriages between same-sex couples is also false. As the
Supreme Court of California made clear in its decision in the Marriage Cases, “affording same-sex couples the opportunity to obtain the designation of marriage will not impinge upon the religious freedom of any religious organization, official, or any other person; no religion will be required to change its religious policies or practices with regard to same-sex couples, and no religious officiant will be required to solemnize a marriage in contravention of his or her religious beliefs.” 183 P.2d. 384, 451-52 (2008). That protection for religious views is already written into the California Constitution. Article I, section 4 guarantees “[f]ree exercise and enjoyment of religion without discrimination or preference,” and that is true even if a religion forbids conduct that the state permits. The First Amendment to the United States Constitution also already protects a religion’s decisions about whether to solemnize and recognize particular marriages. So, for example, a religion is free to treat only marriages between members of its faith as valid – or even to excommunicate members who marry outside the faith – even though the state permits marriages between individuals regardless of their religious identity and cannot punish individuals’ failure to follow religious commands. The same protections clearly apply in the case of same-sex marriages.
No church will be required to perform or to recognize such marriages. No church’s tax-exempt
status will be affected by its decisions about whether to solemnize marriages between same-sex
couples. Current law affects only the civil institution of marriage.
Third, the claim that Proposition 8 is necessary to prevent public schools from teaching
issues relating to marriage by same-sex couples to children whose parents oppose that instruction is false. Existing California law already provides parents with an absolute right to review all materials provided as part of a school’s comprehensive sexual health education program and to have their children excused from participation. Cal. Educ. Code § 51240; see also Citizens for Parental Rights v. San Mateo County Bd. of Educ., 124 Cal. Rptr. 68, 80-82 (Cal. Ct. App. 1st App. Dist. 1975) (discussing the prior version of this longstanding policy). Nothing about Proposition 8 will change this rule, and Proposition 8 adds nothing to the protection of parental rights already provided by law.
Kathryn Abrams
Herma Hill Kay Distinguished Professor of
Law
UC-Berkeley School of Law
Scott Altman
Vice Dean and Virginia S. and Fred H. Bice
Professor of Law
University of Southern California Gould
School of Law
Diane Marie Amann
Professor of Law
University of California, Davis School of Law
Vikram Amar
Associate Dean for Academic Affairs and
Professor of Law
University of California, Davis, School of Law
Angelo N. Ancheta
Assistant Professor of Law
Santa Clara University School of Law
R. Richard Banks
Jackson Eli Reynolds Professor of Law
Stanford Law School
Ash Bhagwat
Professor of Law
University of California, Hastings College of the Law
Grace Ganz Blumberg
Professor of Law
UCLA School of Law
Paul Brest
Dean Emeritus
Stanford Law School
Rebecca Brown
Newton Professor of Constitutional Law
USC Gould School of Law
Alan Brownstein
Professor of Law
Boochever and Bird Chair for the Study and
Teaching of Freedom and Equality
UC Davis School of Law
Kim Buchanan
Assistant Professor
University of Southern California Gould
School of Law
Patricia A. Cain
Inez Mabie Distinguished Professor of Law
Santa Clara University
Erwin Chemerinsky
Founding Dean
University of California, Irvine School of Law
Eric C. Christiansen
Associate Professor of Law
Academic Co-Director, Honors Lawyering Program
Co-Director, GGU-Paris Nanterre
Comparative Law Program
Golden Gate University School of Law
William Cohen
C. Wendell and Edith M. Carlsmith Professor, Emeritus
Stanford Law School
Jan C. Costello
Professor of Law
Loyola Law School - Loyola Marymount University
David B. Cruz
Professor of Law
University of Southern California Gould School of Law
Mary L. Dudziak
Judge Edward J. and Ruey L. Guirado
Professor of Law, History and Political Science
University of Southern California Law School
David L. Faigman
John F. Digardi Distinguished Professor of Law
University of California, Hastings College of the Law
Deborah L. Forman
Professor of Law
J. Allan Cook & Mary Schalling Cook Children's Law Scholar
Whittier Law School
Philip Frickey
Alexander F. and May T. Morrison Professor of Law
UC Berkeley School of Law
Thomas C. Grey
Nelson Bowman Sweitzer and Marie B.
Sweitzer Professor of Law, Emeritus
Stanford Law School
Pratheepan Gulasekaram
Assistant Professor
Santa Clara University School of Law
Elizabeth L. Hillman
Professor of Law
University of California Hastings College of Law
Joan Heifetz Hollinger
Professor and Lecturer-in-Residence in Family Law
University of California, Berkeley
Marina Hsieh
Assistant Dean for Academic & Professional Development
Santa Clara University Law School
Leslie Gielow Jacobs
Director, Capital Center for Government Law
& Policy and Professor of Law
Pacific McGeorge School of Law
Courtney G. Joslin
Acting Professor of Law
UC Davis School of Law, King Hall
Pamela S. Karlan
Kenneth and Harle Montgomery Professor of
Public Interest Law
Stanford Law School
Kenneth L. Karst
David G. Price and Dallas P. Price Professor of Law Emeritus
UCLA School of Law
Herma Hill Kay
Barbara Nachtrieb Armstrong Professor of Law
University of California, Berkeley
Ellen S. Kreitzberg
Professor of Law
Santa Clara University School of Law
Brian K. Landsberg
Distinguished Professor and Scholar
Pacific McGeorge School of Law
Carlton F.W. Larson
Acting Professor of Law
UC Davis School of Law
Lawrence Lessig
C. Wendell and Edith M. Carlsmith Professor of Law
Stanford Law School
Goodwin Liu
Associate Dean and Professor of Law
UC Berkeley School of Law
Jean C. Love
John A. and Elizabeth H. Sutro Professor of Law
Santa Clara University School of Law
Maya Manian
Associate Professor
University of San Francisco School of Law
Lawrence C. Marshall
Associate Dean for Public Service and
Clinical Education & David & Stephanie
Mills Director of Clinical Education
Stanford Law School
John E.B. Myers
Distinguished Professor and Scholar
University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law
Camille Gear Rich
Assistant Professor of Law
USC Gould School of Law
Margaret M. Russell
Professor
Santa Clara University School of Law
Jane S. Schacter
William Nelson Cromwell Professor of Law
Stanford Law School
Darien Shanske
Associate Professor
University of California Hastings College of the Law
John Cary Sims
Professor of Law
Pacific McGeorge School of Law
Edward Steinman
Professor of Law
Santa Clara University School of Law
Kathleen M. Sullivan
Stanley Morrison Professor of Law and
Former Dean
Stanford Law School
Jonathan D. Varat
Professor of Law
University of California, Los Angeles School of Law
Michael S. Wald
Jackson Eli Reynolds Professor of Law, Emeritus
Stanford Law School
Kelly Weisberg
Professor of Law
University of California, Hastings College of the Law
Lois A. Weithorn
Professor of Law
University of California, Hastings College of the Law
University of California
Stephanie M. Wildman
Professor of Law and Director, Center for
Social Justice and Public Service
Santa Clara University School of Law
Michael Zamperini
Professor of Law
Golden Gate University School of Law
Titles and Institutional Affiliations Are Included Only for Purposes of Identification
Thursday, October 30, 2008
A long long time ago. . .
Thanks to Facebook, friends from high school are no longer long gone (in case you're wondering, there's no contest to see how often I can use 'long' or some version thereof in this post) and we see how we've all aged. It's fabulous.
One those great high school friends (thanks, Caddie!) made this PSA (with more to come). The No on 8 campaign has some great videos on their site too: check out the videos.
Also, remember how the Yes campaign was all up in arms about parents taking their kids to their teacher's wedding? Here's what the parents of those kids (kids!) who were in the video had to say about the Yes campaign using their kids' images without consent.
Wednesday, October 29, 2008
It's personal
The attacks are implicitly and sometimes explicitly saying that gays don't deserve to be treated the same as everyone else. People deny this. They say there are a host of other reasons -- then they start spouting off their knowledge of the law.
I've got to tell you, I love the law. I love it for its hopes and aspirations, for its flaws and wrong turns, for its history, and for what it could be. So when people start using the law to further their own ignorance and arguments that have no basis in fact, and were largely gathered from what they learned on those super-accurate court dramas (or, now, from their pastors), it's personal. It's a personal attack on something that's of monumental importance.
When the legal arguments run out, it comes down to 'I don't have to accept homosexuality and you can't make me.' I don't want to make anyone do anything. But understand that this is personal. Being on this side of discrimination and on the receiving end of the hate is painful and scary and profoundly disappointing. I know that people don't think it's about hate or fear or about gay people in particular. It is, though. Taking away someone's rights, singling out a group, and then belittling the importance of it is unfair and wrong and it's not what this state or this country should be known for.
I'm a community-minded person. I think that people are stronger together than separate. I think that working hard for other people is better than going home and watching tv. I know I can only do so much. I know I can't fight for every cause. But when I can, I do, and it's better than not. We're all connected. I know that the ramifications of this issue are not just about me, or just about being gay, or just about any one thing. It's about how we as a society want to relate to each other. We as a people.
The 'hate the sin, love the sinner' does not absolve the attack(er), in my mind. Being told that people Hate something that goes to the core of who I am, oh but don't worry, I'm still loved . . . it's bulls**t (excuse me). I am my successes, my failures, my love, my family, my work, my joy, my pain, my life. Telling me that you hate the 'gayness' is not going to make me straight. It's not going to make me go to hell. It's not going to 'preserve your marriage.'
It's going to drive a wedge between us that no amount of loving the sinner can remove.
This battle is as hurtful and divisive as it is hopeful and unifying. The support from unlikely sources is heartening, even as I'm dismayed at the coalition of churches who aim to pass Prop 8. When you get tired of hearing about Prop 8 and the connected issues, when you are ready to blow it off and minimize its importance, think of the individual it singles out. Think of your friends and neighbors. Think of the constitution that is worth nothing if it does not protect us -- all of us. Think of yourself and your place in our community (large and small). And when you start to say, "yeah, I'm voting yes, but it's nothing personal," think again.
It's personal.
**The "Yes" campaign is calling folks and explaining to them that if they support gay marriage, they should vote yes on Prop 8. Make sure your friends and family know that voting NO preserves equality.**
The truth about Religion
To the argument that same-sex marriages will result in churches losing their tax exempt status or being forced to marry same –sex couples.
This is absolutely false. No one can name a single church in Massachusetts that has lost its tax exempt status or been forced to marry same-sex couples.
The California supreme court’s decision explicitly denied that clergy could be forced to officiate at same-sex marriages. The Court said:
“affording same-sex couples the opportunity to obtain the designation of marriage will not impinge upon the religious freedom of any religious organization, official, or any other person; no religion will be required to change its religious policies or practices with regard to same-sex couples, and no religious officiant will be required to solemnize a marriage in contravention of his or her religious beliefs.” 183 P.2d. 384, 451-52 (2008).
Churches are religious associations and their decisions about who may participate in their services and ceremonies is fully protected by the first amendment. In Boy Scouts v. Dale, the Court held that the Boy Scouts had a constitutional right to deny membership to gay scouts. Can anyone seriously doubt that religious congregations would receive at least as much protection than the boy scouts?
If some conflicts do arise in the future (about religious institutions extending health care benefits to the same-sex spouse of an employee, for example), the way to deal with that eventuality is through a religious exemption or accommodation – not by banning same-sex marriage. See my (unpublished) op-ed.
The op-ed:
Proponents of Proposition 8, the constitutional amendment that would eliminate the right of same-sex couples to marry in
Basically, they are arguing that the right of gays and lesbians to marry and the right of religious communities to follow the dictates of their faith are a zero sum game. Californians have to choose between respecting the right of same-sex couples to marry and protecting the free exercise of religion.
That’s just not true.
As a professor of constitutional law whose area of expertise is church-state issues, I have been working to defend and promote religious liberty for almost 20 years. I’ve helped religious congregations fight land use regulations that burden the operation of their houses of worship. I stood along side Catholic Charities when it challenged a state law requiring Catholic organizations to violate their beliefs by providing insurance coverage to their employees for medical contraceptives. I worked hard (although unsuccessfully) to convince our legislature and governor to adopt a religious freedom restoration act for our state.
I care a great deal about religious liberty, and I can tell you without hesitation that we do not have to unfairly limit the right of same-sex couples to marry to defend religious freedom in our state.
I understand that recognizing the legal right of same-sex couples to marry may create a conflict with the practices of some religious individuals and institutions. That can happen. In a religiously diverse society, it is common for public policies to create conflicts with religious beliefs and practices.
But the appropriate and accepted way to deal with these conflicts is to create accommodations that protect religious liberty in those limited situations where a problem arises -- not to reject the public policy itself in its entirety.
There are so many examples that prove this point that it is hard to understand how anyone could challenge this reality. We respect religious pacifists by allowing conscientious objectors to avoid conscription. But no one suggests that to avoid a conflict with the beliefs of religious pacifists we should disband our military forces.
We understand that laws prohibiting discrimination on the basis of religion or gender in employment can cause a conflict with the hiring decisions of religious institutions. But we do not need to repeal our employment discrimination statutes to protect the Catholic Church from having to hire women as priests or to allow a
When public schools hold classes on the Jewish High Holy Days, they cause a conflict for observant Jewish families. But no one thinks that the solution to this problem is to close the schools for all religious holidays. Instead, we grant the children of religious minorities an excused absence so they can practice their faith without penalty.
In all of these cases and countless other, we affirm both the public policy and religious liberty. We reject the false dichotomy that we have to choose one or the other.
But that’s not what the proponents of Proposition 8 are demanding when they seek to eliminate the right of same-sex couples to marry. They aren’t arguing for religious accommodations in those limited situations when recognizing the right of same-sex couples to marry might interfere with the ability of religious individuals and institutions to practice their faith. Instead, they are insisting that same-sex couples must be denied the right to marry – even though in the great majority of circumstances, the marriage of same-sex couples will not interfere in any way with anyone’s religious practice.
That’s neither right nor fair – and it certainly isn’t necessary to protect religious liberty.
Moreover, there’s one other important point the proponents of Proposition 8 don’t seem to understand. If we are going to protect religious freedom in
Religious people need to be free to do that. So do gays and lesbians.
If we are going to create a society that recognizes the autonomy and liberty of everyone, regardless of what their religious beliefs or sexual orientation may be, we need to understand that the very best way to persuade our neighbors to respect our rights is to demonstrate that we are willing to respect their rights. If religious people want a secure foundation for protecting religious liberty in
In this election, we can affirm both the right of religious liberty and the right to marry in
Alan Brownstein
Professor of Law
UC Davis
The Truth about Education
On Education, he said this:
As the attached press release [pasted below] indicates, this is simply false. Legalizing same-sex marriages says nothing about what is taught in public school and California law requires notice and opt-outs to protect parents when sensitive material is taught in the classroom.
Moreover, this argument makes no sense. There are legitimate issues that deserve to be discussed about what is taught in public schools – but no one has ever suggested before that this issue should control how we define fundamental rights in our society. There is an issue about teaching students about contraceptives and birth control. The way to deal with that is develop rules for teaching sexually sensitive materials – as California has done. It would be absurd to suggest that we should ban the sale and distribution of contraceptives to adults to avoid having this issue discussed in public school.
Or consider religious beliefs and practices. Again there is a legitimate issue about how we should teach about the various religions practiced in our state in public schools. But no one thinks that the way to avoid having teachers inappropriately discuss different religions or to avoid having them suggest that particular faiths are valid or legitimate is to deny those religious communities the right to practice their faith.
Finally, whatever happens with regard to same-sex marriage, public schools will still have to wrestle with how they talk about same-sex families and civil unions. Prohibiting same-sex couples from marrying with no resolve the issue.
The Press Release:
EDUCATION LEADERS SAY YES ON PROP 8 ADS ARE SHAMEFUL
Eastin continued. "Not one word in Prop 8 mentions education and no child can be forced, against the will of their parents, to attend any health-related class.
Tuesday, October 28, 2008
Buying votes
I got a little choked up.
I guess I know for whom I'll be voting.
[Well . . . I was going to vote for him anyway after speaking with him at Darcy's place last week.]
Monday, October 27, 2008
Misunderstandings
2. The courts cannot, will not, and have not infringed on any rights provided by the U.S. constitution.
3. Courts are the proper place to decide civil rights issues for the very reasons we've seen over the last few months: they are emotional, messy, and squarely in the courts' purview. One of the courts' jobs is to protect the minority from the tyranny of the majority.
Thomas Jefferson, in his first inaugural address in 1801 said, "Though the will of the majority is in all cases to prevail, that will to be rightful must be reasonable;...the minority possess their equal rights, which equal law must protect, and to violate would be oppression." The law provides protection when the majority cannot see beyond their emotional reasons for eliminating rights.
4. Some people think churches will be forced to marry gays and lesbians should Prop 8 pass. It's not true. There remains a separation of church and state. There remains people who don't force a church that doesn't want them to marry them under their religions, within their walls.
5. There is a difference between California's existing Unruh Civil Rights Act (This law provides protection from discrimination by all business establishments (not churches) in California, including housing and public accommodations, because of: Age, Ancestry, Color, Disability, National Origin, Race, Religion, Sex, Sexual Orientation) and Proposition 8. Proposition 8 would write discrimination into the constitution. The Unruh Act protects California citizens who belong to a protected class. People have been suing under the Unruh Act (e.g. the Dr. in San Diego who refused to perform complete fertility services for a lesbian couple). People will continue to sue under the civil rights provisions of California law when they are discriminated against. Sometimes they will win.
This has nothing to do with Proposition 8.
6. The biggest newspaper in Alaska endorsed Obama for President (that's not a misunderstanding, I don't think).
7. Civil unions are not the same as marriage. First, they're not the same. If they were the same, folks wouldn't be all up in arms to eliminate the right for gays. Second, here's one way they are different. If you and your spouse live in California and then go to Colorado, and your spouse gets run over by a touring bus, you have all the rights in Colorado that are afforded to you in California by virtue of your marriage. If you have a civil union and the same situation occurs, you have a 'friend' with whom you have traveled and you have no rights: the hospital that tries furiously to save your spouse's life will just as furiously try to find next of kin, because it's not you. No rights. Here's another way: separate is not equal. Never has been, never will be.
Sunday, October 26, 2008
Down by the River
Saturday's NCAC ride was as gorgeous as last month, with a smaller group, and a different direction down the river (different river, actually). What a gorgeous day. It was the kind of ride that reminds me why I get on my bike over and over. Especially because it was flat -- I'd rather ride on flatland. I was talking up the '09 ride with Erin (below) and Ron (left) and telling them all the fun details (no, you don't have to carry your own bags, yes, you have to sleep on the ground, yes, there is lots and lots of food, no, you don't have to cook it). It reminded me that I should start fund-raising. Hadn't I started by this time last year? I can't remember.
How 'bout that helmet-cam up there? I didn't get many photos on Saturday because I was busy going fast and talking (but not usually at the same time). I'm thinking of getting a trainer so that
I can keep riding this winter (just not outside) and work on speed. I think I probably have a little longer outside, considering it's Oct 26, and today's high was 85 degrees, but if it ever does get cold, I'd like to keep cycling.I tried to get some photos of the gigantic homes that line the river (some of them on stilts, but it's a flood plain, afterall), but they were hard to capture. This is one of them that seemed to be part of a giant compound of giant homes.
I rode back on my own and tried to convince myself that if I rode really really fast, I could catch someone who turned around early. It worked up until the last 2 miles or so -- I maintained an 18-22mph pace for most of the distance.

If Mia hadn't have gone to the vet today in a semi-rush, maybe I could just buy myself a trainer. Instead, I got to find out about gross (and expensive) cat disorders (that are thankfully fixable in a couple of visits). Poor Mia.
Friday, October 24, 2008
Education
1. I wish I had a book club still. I have been reading really interesting books, and I'd like to discuss them. Actually, I wish I had a literature class, because my book club wasn't really about delving into the books' issues. Lit classes way more fun. Geek-fun. I just want a lit class with adults in it, though, so I might have to either create a book club full of English majors (oh! or professors -- way more fun!) or at least people interested in literature, or look into "community education," or just give it up.2. People have co-opted Proposition 8 for their own fear-based purposes. So I'm going to co-opt my cycling blog with some Prop-8 related information. It's only fair that my 4 readers suffer through it with me. Why is it fair? It's my blog.
3. Education is important. We have a whole code here in CA about it. A whole state department. The federal government gets involved. Local school boards and communities get involved. Parents too. We're compared internationally to students and statistics regarding successes (or failures) in education.
It starts from when we're born (at least)-- our parents educate us in a variety of ways. They help us learn to use words and language, they teach us their values, they (often) teach us to read and write, they foster curiosity so that education becomes a life-long endeavor (see #1, por ejemplo), they teach us judgment, and discerning, and sometimes they pass on their likes and dislikes. When I was young, my mom home-schooled us for a while, with some other families. We also went to Sunday school and church. We had family dinners and lots of talking (if there's one thing the Rowans can do, it's talk. . .a lot) and we had a set of encyclopedias that always confused me. I mean, I kind of wanted to read them, but then it seemed like it was kind of boring and I never new what to look for. That's why we have educators.
4. Education can be subtle, and pervasive. There's other stuff we learn too, from a very young age. Take Disney, for example: princess gets into some trouble, or loses her internal compass, or has to overcome adversity (and is always pretty, thin, white, and well-dressed [I'm aware of the movie Mulan, yes]), then she gets her prince (handsome, muscular, tall, white) and they kiss, and then live happily ever after. We are bred to believe we must be be heterosexual, thin, white people with a nice wardrobe. The media demands it. It's called the 'heterosexism' and is interlaced with the 'presumption of heterosexuality.' Barbie and Ken know it. Calvin Klein knows it. If you look around, you might see that there is an onslaught of heterosexual propaganda. It starts when we're very young, and it continues. People don't think of it as propaganda because we're so numb to it. I challenge you to start seeing it, however.
5. Schools. The big arguments in favor of eliminating marriage equality is that kids are going to
learn homosexuality in schools. I've already said I don't know what that means, what some think it means is that California will find itself in Massachusetts's shoes, where a teacher read King and King in a second grade class room. The basic story: the prince is supposed to take a wife, so he meets a bunch of princesses, one of them brought her brother with her, the prince's heart went boom. At the end, there are two princes in a quite-covered kiss.
Kids are sponges for information. The little ones especially, because everything is so new. Our school boards build a curriculum, with parental and governmental input, our teachers teach it in straightforward, creative, traditional, and (or?) innovative ways. Teachers read to their students.
Students who read books in school probably learn about marriage. Not in a lesson necessarily (i.e., 'this is what marriage is') but in picking up the clues from the books. You can imagine a question about, 'what is a step mother?' or 'how did she get from Princess to Queen?' or 'how come that boy doesn't live with his daddy?' These things all get you marriage (or divorce, which you can't have without marriage). Gay people exist in the world. They have lasting commitments. The Yes on 8 folks want to keep them in the 'separate but equal' civil unions, the California Supreme Court recognized that there is a fundamental right to marriage. Either way, to acknowledge it in our libraries (where the MA teacher got the book), on our bookshelves, in our media, and in front of our children will not create a harm. If parents have chosen that homosexuality does not comport with their religious or personal views, parents can explain this to their kids.
When I was a kid, we were vegetarians. We were pretty much the only family that was vegetarian. Growing up, I knew that not eating (most) meat was something that was a belief in my house, but not everyone else's. Friend's parents (and my grandparents) offered to feed us hamburgers or ham sandwiches or bacon. We said, 'no, thank you. We don't eat meat.' It wasn't traumatizing.
6. Prop 8 doesn't have anything to do with education. Nothing in California's education code has schools teaching about marriage. And third, California allows a high level of parental involvement in their children's education and also allows a parent to 'opt-out' of a particular lesson (on behalf of the child).
Further, the anti-marriage-equality folks keep saying that civil unions are the same, and why aren't the gays happy with that? So if they are the same, as the argument goes, nothing is to stop a teacher from reading this fairy tale about happy-ever-after in schools, and then adding, "But in California, we call them "civil unions." Prop 8 isn't going to get you around that. If someone is unhappy with the curriculum, there are avenues to address that. Avenues that do not involve civil rights.
Some kids have gay parents or siblings or family members. Including those children in a discussion would seem to add to educational value, not detract. It's hard to be gay. But it doesn't have to be so hard.
7. There's another fear tactic involving a 'field trip' that a grade school class in S.F. made to go watch their teacher get married. I offer you this quotation from the news article on the event: "A parent came up with the idea for the field trip - a surprise for the teacher on her wedding day."
Parental involvement. The students were not forced along by their teacher so that they could be "indoctrinated into homosexuality," they were driven by their parents.And Prop 8 has nothing to do with that either. If the kids showed up at their teacher's civil union, Prop 8 won't touch that at all. I know it's hard to look past the ways that we're raised, or the thoughts that are so ingrained, we don't know we're having them. Really hard to see two women getting married or two boys kissing and not have some sort of reaction. But having a reaction doesn't mean it's wrong or unnatural or immoral.
Proposition 8 doesn't have to do with education. Proposition 8 is about writing discrimination into the California Constitution (largely based on religious morality). Proposition 8 is about eliminating the "fundamental right of marriage" from a particular group of people, but allowing it for another.
Thursday, October 23, 2008
Post-Promenade Party w/ Princesses and Princes
Plus, the rose-giver from the ride showed up with his dad, who is Ann's husband and Vanessa's father-in-law (got that?) and it was fun to see them again.
(Don't you love how we all go with the decor of the bar?)
The girls gave me a massage and a gift certificate to the best frozen yogurt place ever and a lovely card. And Ann and Vanessa made all of us very sweet photo albums with photos from the last few months. It's such a thoughtful gift.
Here's Christine and Jana (left to right).
Christine was gunning for 'most improved cyclist' -- she bought her road bike not very long before starting with this group and was doing fantastically -- but she opted for 'most dramatic finish' when she sprung from her bike only 1/2 way through training, slammed herself onto the asphalt, scraped up her legs, arms, and who knows what else, and fractured her humerus. Christine, if you didn't want to ride with us anymore, you could have just said so.
Ann and Vanessa (left to right):
Those are just reasons to like her, though. Vanessa gets 'most fashionable' (the 'outfits' obviously) and 'most willing.' Vanessa was willing to go any speed, any time. Usually she lead the pack, but she was also willing to slow it down and have an endurance, rather than speed day. One day it was just me, Jana, and Vanessa, and we road out for about 10 miles, and then turned around to come back. On the way back, I set the pace at about 17.5-19.5 mph. Vanessa kept up with no complaints. In fact, she stopped talking altogether.
Ann told Vanessa she could use her bike and somehow Vanessa turned that into getting Ann to sign up to ride with us as well (we're happy it did). The first time I rode with Ann (which was her second Jill ride, and our 4th meeting or so), she asked if I thought she should quit the team. I don't think she knew that she was talking to someone who doesn't think anyone should ever quit cycling, unless they have to pee or something. Ann was concerned that she was going to hold
people back and they wouldn't get to ride how they wanted. I told her not to quit and see how it goes. The next ride, we were coming back on the infamous River Road and I came up beside Ann, set a 15mph pace and told her to hold it until the end of the road (about a mile and a half). I dropped behind her and watched my speedometer. 15mph. 14.5mph. 15mph. 16 mph. 17mph. 84 rpm (whoops, I pushed the wrong button). 18mph! And she held 18 for the remainder of that road and most of the next.Long story short: Ann is the 'most willing to defeat the Voices' and also my favorite closet-speed-racer.
Jen and Heather:
Jen gets the award for being most likely to fall off her bike for no apparent reason and still not get hurt (much). But, she also gets the 'most encouraging rider' prize because there was never a time that Jen was not telling folks how well they were doing or encouraging them to see what a fantastic accomplishment they'd had, or to let the others know that even though she makes it look easy, she's right there with them. It was fun to have such a sincere cheerleader.
Have you ever seen such a smiley bunch? You'd think it was November 5th, or something.
Wednesday, October 22, 2008
Did anyone else
I've been thinking about the juxtaposition of talking about preserving the right of marriage (and equality) and saying I was going to get married for the perks. Beside the fact that my whining is in jest (unless I meet someone really handy or really wealthy, of course), it seems that having the right to participate in marriage means making those big decisions regarding whether one marries for love or for 55 hours.
I sort of alluded to the proponents' "arguments" regarding why the right of marriage should be taken away from a segment of the population ("it's obvious that they are a way to justify discrimination"). An argument that uses the word, "obvious," is obviously weak on its face; but if someone has questions about why the 'Yes on 8' talking points don't pass muster, I'm happy to discuss.
Tuesday, October 21, 2008
Do unto others, unless . . .

I've been told that the "No on 8" folks are mean and attacking the Yes folks and "wanting tolerance, but not showing any." Interesting. I've also learned that the [Republican] strategy includes two main components: 1) repeat a lie over and over and over until people believe it's the truth; 2) identify all the characteristics and dirty tricks in your own campaign, and accuse the other side of doing just that.
I think the Yes folks get tired of hearing from people that they are bigoted or hateful or discriminating, because most of them are doing and believing what their churches tell them to do and believe, and how could the church be wrong? What the Yes folks don't understand is that it feels very hateful to be on this side of a denial of rights. It feels worse than getting picked last for dodge ball. It feels like every other person has been picked for the team, even the ones who are going to purposefully throw the game, and being told, 'you can't play.' It's hateful and arbitrary. I might not be the best dodge ball player in the world, but I'd rather not just watch.
But we're not supposed to talk about that, because people who support Prop 8 have all kinds of reasons for supporting it that make sense to them and they don't think that they're hateful.

- Children/procreation
- Education
- Denial of religious freedoms
- Law suits
- Denigration of society
- And many more.
Looking at these one by one, it's obvious that they are a way to justify discrimination, and don't hold a lot of weight. I'm a little frustrated with the "Christians" who are espousing these views. My favorite though is that "children will be taught homosexuality in schools." I don't know what this means, but the possibilities are sort of interesting. If all they mean is that kids will learn that there's such a thing as marriage and that two people who love each other a lot get married, it seems the kids aren't going to spontaneously combust from that. People gasp and say, 'our children are going to be taught that homosexuality is normal!' I sort of laughed when I heard that at first -- but then I realized it wasn't a joke. First, homosexuality is pretty normal -- it's just that not everyone gets to be gay. And second, it seems to be that if you actually teach kids that, we'd all be better off. Isn't that kind of the point of equality?
Although, I'd like to think that what they mean when they say kids will be learning homosexuality in schools, they're going to take the boys to decorating school and the girls to Home Depot.
I admit that there are a lot of things about our society that don't seem to be going well. I just don't think the gays can shoulder it all. I don't think homosexuality can be blamed for natural disasters any more than for the "unraveling of the moral fabric of society." It's a lot to carry. Even though you see those gay boys in the gym for hours at a time and then going off to strut their buffness, they're not that strong.
Maybe if we stop focusing on homosexuality and fighting about whether it's a choice or biology, moral or not, bad for our kids or just a part of life, etc, we could take a look at what's really going on. Maybe.
Saturday, October 18, 2008
Success!
It was a little chilly and dreary in the morning, but we had our wings and our tiara (and people told us how (and I quote) "adorable" we were, so we knew it was going to be a fabulous day.
They were right: we were definitely adorable. But we were also strong, confident and totally prepared. Being adorable is a bonus (But thanks, Strange Man with a Camera!).
Who but Vanessa would have taken up this guy's offer who said, "hey, you want to hoola-hoop while I take photos?" Yeah. We love Vanessa.
Jen posing at one of the rest stops. She's pretty proud of that Washington Jersey. Who am I to talk? Stay tuned for photos of my Colorado Jersey that my mom sent (thanks, Mom!).
In addition to Ann, Jana, Vanessa, and Jen (seen here doing their victory lap), keep up a great pace for the whole ride, and hung out at the last rest stop so we could all ride in together. Jana in particular enforced this joint-finish-line rule and we were all glad she did. After 10+ weeks of riding together, we were glad to finish it off Jill-style. I think everyone was a little bummed to be finishing the ride, because it meant no more Thursday evening and Sunday mornings with the Jills. And let me tell you, in addition to eing adorable, we're also a great group of girls who like hanging out together.
The most successful part of the training (in my opinion), was not just finishing this ride (and kicking butt while we did it), but that everyone intends to continue riding. Jen even signed up for NCAC! Hurray!
This week I've been griping to people that I need to get married because I need a second income (teaching a spinning class a couple times a week does not, unfortunately, equal a second income) AND I need someone around who is handier than I am. Well, being handy at all would be handier than me, so it's a low bar.
1. Second income so I can convince someone to pay half my grocery bill (also provides someone to cook for when I get the groceries home).
2. Fix things like fences, build cool gardening contraptions, paint stuff, have tools.
3. Bring roses when I do something extraordinary (and sometimes ordinary), or tell me that I'm really cool and adorable, but NOT because they want to take my picture for some promotional materials, but because they actually believe it.
I'm sure I'll think of things to add to that list.
Here we are looking adorable again. See Christine there on the far end? Her sling is off and she's back at the gym! In another month, she'll be back on the bike! Hopefully she'll ride with us again (and hopefully Ron will let her).
Congratulations everyone! It was such a great time, and I'm looking forward to your continued successes.
Thursday, October 16, 2008
Route for NCAC Ride 10/25
Here is an approximate map of the October Ride, meet at Butch N Nellies at 8:30/8:45:
Or go here: http://www.bikely.com/maps/bike-path/213971
Worth a few minutes
Or go here.
The upcoming election is distressing for so many reasons. I don't want to wake up on November 5th to a world where we're repeating the downward spiral of the last eight years, and a world where I don't feel welcome. . . maybe even [hated]. Make sure you vote. And pass on to your family and friends in California (and Arizona and Florida) that there's no reason to be scared of gay marriage. Our lives will not be turned upside down. Our children will not be converted. Our religions will not be threatened. Our marriages will not fail.
Really.
